Selected menu has been deleted. Please select the another existing nav menu.
=

‘Natural parents have preferential right’: HC orders paternal aunt to hand over child’s custody

Lorem ipsum dolor sit amet consectetur. Facilisis eu sit commodo sit. Phasellus elit sit sit dolor risus faucibus vel aliquam. Fames mattis.

HTML tutorial

A couple who moved to Canada in the hope of building a better future for their family returned to India with their immigration papers in place and a visa secured for their little daughter. But what awaited them was a legal battle they perhaps had never anticipated: the relatives with whom they had temporarily left the child refused to give her back, claiming that she had been given to them in adoption.In an unusual family custody dispute, the Punjab and Haryana High Court has ordered the child’s paternal aunt and her husband to hand over her custody to her biological parents, holding that their continued refusal to do so was “wholly illegal and unlawful”.The Bench made it clear that the welfare of a child remained the paramount consideration in custody matters, but natural parents had a preferential right to custody when pitted against other relatives.“Not only the law but common sense also says so,” Justice Vikram Aggarwal observed.The order, initially passed by Justice Aggarwal, was upheld by a Division Bench comprising Justice Suvir Sehgal and Justice Rajesh Gaur.The case dates back to December 2023, when the child’s mother left for Canada after securing admission to a college to pursue a course in Global Business Management. She had moved abroad “with the aim of securing a bright future for her minor daughter and her family”. Her husband followed in February 2024.Their daughter, born on November 25, 2021, could not accompany them because her visa had not been granted. She was initially left with her father’s joint family as “a temporary arrangement”.However, a medical emergency altered the arrangement. The father’s elder brother was diagnosed with stage III cancer of the mouth and referred to AIIMS, Bathinda. As the family became occupied with his treatment, the girl was sent to her paternal aunt.The parents subsequently completed the immigration formalities for their daughter. She was granted a Canadian visa in January 2025, valid until October 10, 2028. Both parents also obtained work permits in 2026. The couple returned to India to take their daughter along but find that the aunt and her husband were unwilling to hand her over.The relatives, however, put forward a different version of events. In their reply before the High Court, they claimed that the couple had orally given the child to them in adoption before leaving for Canada and had promised to execute the adoption documents upon their return.The aunt and her husband also relied on the child’s school identity card, which described her as the daughter of the aunt’s husband.They further alleged that the parents were seeking custody because the Canadian Government provided financial assistance for children.The Bench was also told that the relatives had also instituted a civil suit in Ambala seeking a declaration regarding the child’s custody. They argued that the rights of the parties should be determined in those proceedings and that a habeas corpus petition was not maintainable.The High Court rejected the objection, holding that a habeas corpus petition for custody of a minor was maintainable in cases involving wrongful deprivation of custody. Observing that it was “very normal for any parents to leave the child behind in the joint family in case of some problem in the immigration process”, the court said it was equally natural for parents to entrust the child to her paternal aunt when a medical emergency affected the joint family.“The argument that it was a case of an oral adoption is not acceptable and that too at this stage,” Justice Aggarwal observed, adding that “disputed questions can never be decided in a writ petition”.The court clarified that issues relating to adoption would have to be decided in the civil suit already instituted by the relatives.The court also consciously avoided putting the four-year-old in a position where she would have to choose between the two sides. Noting that she had been living with her paternal aunt and her husband for nearly three years, it explained that it had not interacted with her to ascertain her wishes because “it would not have been in the interest of the child to ask her as to whom she wants to live with”.Holding that the relatives’ continued custody was unlawful, the court noted that the parents had processed her immigration documents, secured her visa and obtained the necessary consent for her to travel to Canada.“Under the circumstances, there would absolutely be no reason for respondents No.4 and 5 to hold on to the custody of the minor child,” the court observed.Allowing the habeas corpus petition, the High Court directed the aunt and her husband to hand over the child’s custody to her parents. However, it emphasised that the restoration of custody must be handled “with due sensitivity and without causing any avoidable trauma to the child”.

HTML tutorial

Tags :

Search

Popular Posts


Useful Links

Selected menu has been deleted. Please select the another existing nav menu.

Recent Posts

©2025 – All Right Reserved. Designed and Developed by JATTVIBE.