There are documents that establish a marriage, others that prove ownership or death. And then there are documents that can unexpectedly alter the course of a court proceeding. A wedding invitation card did precisely that in the Punjab and Haryana High Court.A woman seeking the transfer of a civil suit from Phillaur to Mukerian cited her father’s illness and bedridden condition as reasons why travelling nearly 120 km one way to attend court proceedings would be extremely difficult for her.There was, however, one glaring problem with her claim. Her father had been dead for seven to eight years. And the document that exposed this contradiction in the courtroom was not a death certificate, but a wedding invitation card.The unusual episode unfolded before Justice Mandeep Pannu, who was hearing a transfer application filed by a Mukerian resident against her brother-in-law, who had instituted a civil suit seeking recovery of damages before the Phillaur Additional Civil Judge (Senior Division). But she wanted the proceedings transferred to a competent court at Mukerian, in Hoshiarpur district.Her counsel argued that she was residing at a village in Mukerian tehsil, and that Phillaur was approximately 120 kilometres away. She had no independent source of income and was unable to maintain herself. Her father, poor, sick and bedridden, was living with her, it was added.The respondent’s counsel had a rather different account. Opposing the transfer, she told the court that the applicant was gainfully employed as a nurse and earned approximately Rs 30,000 per month. She further pointed out that the woman’s father had died seven to eight years before the transfer application was filed.The respondent did not leave the assertion unsupported. The counsel placed a wedding invitation card on record, which the woman’s father described as “late”. The word ‘late’ was difficult to overlook. The court examined the rival submissions and the documents. What had initially been presented as a plea of personal hardship acquired an entirely different dimension.Justice Pannu observed: “The applicant has made a false averment regarding the illness and bedridden condition of her father, who was already dead at the time of filing of the present transfer application, which constitutes concealment of a material fact having a direct bearing on the relief sought in the present application.”That observation proved decisive. The court invoked the settled principle that anyone seeking discretionary relief must approach the court with clean hands and disclose all material facts fairly. Justice Pannu observed: “In the present case, the applicant has not only suppressed a material fact but has also sought to seek advantage on the basis of a factually incorrect assertion”.The transfer plea consequently failed. Dismissing the application, the court held: “In view of the circumstances, this court is of the considered opinion that the applicant is not entitled to the discretionary relief of transfer.”


