The Punjab and Haryana High Court has granted the Punjab Government just over 10 days to file a better affidavit explaining why a citizen is required to furnish a voter ID card for coverage under “Mukh Mantri Mawan Dhiyan Satkar Yojana”.The bench of Chief Justice Ashwani Kumar Mishra and Justice Rohit Kapoor also fixed December 15 as the next date of hearing on the petition filed in public interest challenging notification issued by Punjab notifying “Mukh Mantri Mawan Dhiyan Satkar Yojana”. Among other things, the bench was told that the scheme was launched only to secure votes.After addressing the bench during the resumed hearing of the matter, senior counsel representing the state of Punjab, Vikas Singh, sought 10 days’ further time to file a better affidavit explaining the stand of the state, and “clarify the rationale for insisting upon furnishing of voter ID card by a citizen for the grant of coverage under the scheme”. Advocate Prateek Gupta appeared for the Election Commission of India in the matter, while counsel Varun Dutta represented the petitioner.Describing itself as a charitable society working in the field of transparency, good governance, accountability and protection of public interest, petitioner Harbakhsh Charitable Society had earlier contended that the scheme provided monthly financial assistance of Rs 1,500 to women belonging to the Scheduled Caste category and Rs 1,000 to other women registered as voters in the state of Punjab.Appearing before the bench, the petitioner through advocates Dutta and Karan Bhardwaj had contended that scheme notified on April 2 was being challenged “on the ground that its purpose is only to secure votes in favour of the ruling dispensation”.Elaborating, the counsel said Clause 9 of the scheme specified the documentation required to avail benefit under the scheme. “It is asserted that mandatory requirement of voter ID card of Punjab state, issued by the Election Commission of India, for availing benefit under the scheme clearly indicates that object of scheme is only to secure votes from the beneficiaries.”It was further submitted that voter ID card could be one of the documents required for the purposes of identification etc., but requiring it mandatorily for the grant of benefit under the scheme “manifests its purpose i.e., to act as a quid pro quo for securing votes”.


