The Punjab and Haryana High Court has directed the Punjab Public Service Commission (PPSC) to preserve and seal the entire record of the PCS recruitment process. The court has already stayed further selection process pursuant to advertisement dated January 2 last year.Among other things, the bench has asserted that it cannot lose sight of the concerns and questions raised on the petitioners’ behalf in multiple writ petitions, which prima facie were found to be glaring in nature.“If the process of selection is allowed to continue, it may hamper the career of hundreds of candidates, wherein a total number of more than 85,000 applicants have applied for various posts under the advertisement in question,” Justice Sandeep Moudgil asserted. The bench made it clear that complete record pertaining to the selection process – from the date of application submission till scrutiny up to November 18 – would be kept intact and sealed forthwith by PPSC Secretary. It would be submitted to the court by November 23 positively without any fail.You can structure it this way, making Justice Moudgil the subject and keeping the narrative flowing:In his detailed 21-page order, Justice Moudgil flagged several concerns in the recruitment process. Among these was the repeated extension of deadlines for submission of documents, particularly in the sports and Persons with Disabilities (PwD) categories. Justice Moudgil observed that the deadlines had been extended “on almost three occasions”, allegedly by the PPSC secretary alone, without any decision by the commission or the state government.Justice Moudgil also flagged the fact that applications were not scrutinised before either the preliminary or the main examination. The scrutiny was completed only on November 18, after declaration of the mains result on November 4.Discrepancies in question papers also came under scrutiny. Some carried serial numbers while others did not, and the serial numbers printed on different papers had varying patterns and fonts. Justice Moudgil asserted these circumstances were “sufficient to prima facie raise doubt qua the genuineness and fairness of the selection process”.Justice Moudgil also flagged applications submitted under different genders, resulting in candidates being issued roll numbers in both male and female categories, as well as multiple roll numbers being issued to a larger number of applicants. “A number of candidates have submitted online applications under different genders and have been issued roll numbers as such in the male as well as in the female gender, that too in different categories,” the bench observed.Another concern related to the sports category. The court observed that subsequent opportunities to submit Sports Gradation Certificates had prima facie placed candidates who had applied within the prescribed deadline at a disadvantage. These extensions, the bench noted, had “inflated the number of eligible candidates by 361”, who were otherwise ineligible to compete even in the preliminary examination.Justice Moudgil also questioned the pattern of successful candidates in the declared result, observing that it “raises suspicion” in view of the circumstances and specific instances highlighted by the petitioners. The court held that direct evidence of cheating was not indispensable at this stage. It observed that recruitment disputes involving public examinations did not require appreciation of evidence as in a criminal trial. “Nor is it necessary to insist upon the number of actual malpractices being established by direct evidence alone,” it held.Justice Moudgil further observed that the allegations were required to be tested “on the touchstone of Articles 14 and 16 to ensure that there is no illegality or arbitrariness and that the selection process is transparent, fair and has provided equal opportunity to all in these public appointments as advertised”.Before parting with the matter, Justice Moudgil listed the matter for further consideration on December 16.


