The Armed Forces Tribunal (AFT) has held that a recruit is not required to disclose details of any criminal case registered against him while he was a juvenile, and that concealment of such information at the time of enrolment cannot be held against him if it comes to light later.Quashing the dismissal of a soldier by a summary court martial for withholding such information, the Tribunal’s Bench of Justice Rajendra Menon and administrative member Rasika Chaube directed the Army to reinstate him and allow him to undergo training.The Bench ruled that if it was not possible to take him back into service for any reason, including medical unfitness or other grounds under the rules, the applicant shall be deemed to have been reinstated and shall be entitled to all consequential benefits, including pay and allowances up to the date of his release in accordance with the terms of his appointment, and thereafter to pensionary benefits.The soldier was enrolled in the Parachute Regiment in March 2017 and dismissed from service in September 2018 after being tried by a summary court martial. His representations seeking reinstatement were rejected by the authorities.During character verification by the district magistrate concerned, it emerged that when he was 15 years old, two criminal cases had been registered against him. One pertained to theft and dishonest receipt of stolen property in Uttarakhand, while the other involved charges of rioting, voluntarily causing hurt and intentional insult with intent to provoke a breach of peace. He was arrested along with other accused in the cases but was later acquitted.Before the AFT, the soldier contended that he was a juvenile at the time of the alleged offences and that any action taken against him by the Army on account of acts committed during juvenility was unsustainable in law. He argued that under Sections 19 and 21 of the Juvenile Justice (Care and Protection of Children) Act, 2000, he could not be subjected to adverse consequences arising from such proceedings.The Army maintained that although the soldier was a juvenile at the time, he had suppressed information regarding his involvement in criminal cases while seeking enrolment, and therefore the action against him was justified.Referring to earlier judgments of the Supreme Court and the Delhi High Court, the AFT observed that the legislative intent of the Juvenile Justice Act was clear that a juvenile in conflict with law was under no legal obligation to disclose previous involvement in a criminal case.“No action could be taken against him, and the criminal proceedings did not even result in his conviction. Even if he had been convicted, such conviction would not have entailed any disqualification for seeking employment. Taking action against the applicant in the present circumstances is not permissible,” the Bench ruled.


