Selected menu has been deleted. Please select the another existing nav menu.
=

Gen Zhao’s purge is about consolidation of Xi’s power

Lorem ipsum dolor sit amet consectetur. Facilisis eu sit commodo sit. Phasellus elit sit sit dolor risus faucibus vel aliquam. Fames mattis.

HTML tutorial

IN late August, former PLA Commander, Gen Zhao Zongqi, was removed from his position in the Chinese People’s Political Consultative Conference (CPPCC) — an advisory body in the country’s political system. Given that he headed the Western Theatre Command (WTC) during the Doklam standoff and at the beginning of the May 2020 escalation between India and China, which led to the Galwan incident, General Zhao’s removal has been read as a sign that China seeks to improve relations with India, especially given the BRICS summit.

This speculation is part of the same line of thinking in India which explains the Galwan clash as a result of the actions of a rogue local commander rather than one that proceeded with sanction from the highest levels.
Such speculation, however, rests on incorrect assumptions.
First, consider the career trajectory of the senior officers involved in the 2020 incident.
The Western Sector of the boundary dispute with India — Ladakh, Aksai Chin — falls under the geographical area of the WTC, which Gen Zhao commanded, with the Xinjiang and Tibet Military Districts (XMD, TMD) that directly face the Indian border.
While China’s 2019 Defence White Paper places the TMD and XMD alongside the five theatre commands that report to the PLA army, in practice, it would appear that the WTC is in charge of the two Military Districts, and was certainly during the 2020 conflict on the disputed boundary with India.
Under this logic, General Zhao bears the final accountability for the actions in eastern Ladakh in 2020.
General Zhao was not removed from the WTC leadership in the wake of Galwan but only retired when he turned 65 — the retirement age for Generals in the PLA — at the end of 2020.
He then followed what is part of a routine path for retiring Generals: serving as a vice-chairman of the 13th National People’s Congress’ Foreign Affairs Committee from February 2021 onwards. Following the end of this tenure, he was appointed to the 14th CPPCC in 2023 and was a vice-chairman of the Ethnic and Religious Affairs Committee until he was purged.
In between, General Zhao was spotted alongside CPC General Secretary and Central Military Commission (CMC) Chairman Xi Jinping during the latter’s visit to Tibet in August last year.
If his purge stemmed from “military failures” during the 2020 India-China conflict, he could not have carried on to these fairly visible post-retirement political positions and remained active for so long.
Meanwhile, in 2020, the XMD and South XMD that were directly involved in the transgressions and conflict in eastern Ladakh were led by Lt Gen Liu Wanlong and Maj Gen Liu Lin, respectively. If the purges were due to actions provoking an escalation of the India-China border dispute, then this should reflect also in their subsequent career paths.
However, after his tenure at XMD ended in March 2021, Lt Gen Liu Wanlong, too, became a member of the 14th CPPCC in 2023 while Maj Gen Liu Lin was promoted as Commander of the XMD in August 2021.
Explaining the purge
Like all PLA purges, General Zhao’s purge should be understood as part of both a systemic “clean-up” as well as the consolidation of power by Xi Jinping. The fundamental objective of both is to ensure that China is able to achieve its military goals in the future.
The Chinese armed forces have been plagued by corruption and malpractice for decades. While the anti-corruption campaign is, in general, part of Xi’s goal of cleaning up the image of the CPC at a time of economic challenges at home and increasing flux abroad, the fact that the PLA has been targeted so severely from the start must also have to do with the fact that graft began to be perceived as eroding the PLA’s ability to achieve military objectives.
Lending credence to this idea is the fact that over the past four years, PLA purges have cut across every faction, organisational level, function and institution.
Meanwhile, explanations of Chinese actions in India that favour indiscipline as a thesis lead to the assumption that instances like Galwan are likely to be episodic in nature and that an authoritarian system would eventually punish and correct deviations.
But what if the so-called deviation is the norm? The career trajectories of senior Chinese officers post-Galwan as well as the centralisation of power by Xi as CMC Chairman indicating strict control over local commanders underline this reality.
Even if it were assumed that the purge of General Zhao was a delayed response to what happened on the India-China boundary, the more likely reason is not because he provoked an escalation but because he did not carry out the escalation well. Consider, for instance, the PLA’s failure to respond to the Indian Army’s Operation Snow Leopard, which led to the capture of the Kailash heights on August 29-30, 2020.
Finally, forecasts that focus on instability as the major outcome of purges within the PLA’s ranks ignore the possibility that dismissals open up opportunities for officers waiting in the wings, who will then be aligned more closely with the leader’s objectives and be willing to take risks — or be creative — in order to meet those objectives.
If so, this is something that needs to be factored into Indian thinking and planning — not just within its military but also within its diplomatic establishment. This is because the Indian military can expect more provocations all along the LAC which might not necessarily fit any familiar template.
For India’s diplomatic establishment, meanwhile, this would change the implications of current diplomatic parleys and, indeed, the nature of the boundary negotiations themselves. That the current bilateral détente and bonhomie at multilateral forums is tactical might be well understood, but it could be that diplomacy itself might have decreasing marginal utility.

HTML tutorial

Tags :

Search

Popular Posts


Useful Links

Selected menu has been deleted. Please select the another existing nav menu.

Recent Posts

©2025 – All Right Reserved. Designed and Developed by JATTVIBE.