The Delhi High Court has dismissed a US woman’s petition seeking conversion of her tourist visa into a spouse visa on the basis of her marriage to an Indian citizen, holding that the Centre was justified in suspecting that the marriage could be one of convenience to secure immigration benefits.Justice Amit Mahajan observed that the immigration authorities had sufficient grounds to scrutinise the woman’s application, considering her successive matrimonial relationships, prolonged stay in India and previous attempts to obtain immigration benefits through marriage.“The explanation furnished by the Respondents in the Counter Affidavit is satisfactory and the suspicion is well-founded,” the court said in its November 17 order.The petitioner, Lisa Hall Srivastava, had married Mohammad Wasim Akram on December 7, 2025, according to Muslim rites and customs. Their marriage was subsequently solemnised before a Marriage Officer under the Special Marriage Act on March 18, 2026.She approached the court after the Foreigners Regional Registration Office (FRRO), Delhi, did not grant her application to convert her existing e-tourist visa, valid until September 14, 2027, into an Entry (X-1) visa, commonly known as a spouse visa. She alleged that she and her husband were subjected to repeated enquiries, particularly over the age difference between them.However, the Centre told the court that the scrutiny was not based merely on the age difference but on several circumstances surrounding her immigration history and matrimonial relationships.According to the government’s affidavit, the woman was earlier married to George Daniel Williamson, an Overseas Citizen of India (OCI) cardholder, through whom she had obtained OCI status. Following the dissolution of that marriage in July 2021, her OCI status was cancelled in November 2023.She subsequently entered into another matrimonial relationship with Deepak Srivastava in December 2022 and sought visa conversion and extension on that basis.However, her applications could not succeed due to deficiencies in supporting documents. The second marriage ended in November 2025, before any change in her immigration status could materialise.The authorities pointed out that her present marriage was her third and also flagged her prolonged stay in India, previous applications seeking immigration benefits through matrimonial relationships, residential arrangements and explanations regarding her source of income and means of sustenance.The Centre further submitted that she had been residing as a tenant in premises owned by her present husband even before their marriage. Records also indicated that Akram had accompanied her during the period when she was pursuing immigration benefits through her previous marriage with Srivastava.Taking these circumstances together, the competent authority had formed a prima facie opinion that the present marriage was one of convenience and that the possibility of financial or contractual arrangements to facilitate immigration benefits could not be ruled out.The court also noted that the woman’s application had been processed as an Exit Permit Request, which was stated to be pending due to her non-compliance.Rejecting her plea, Justice Mahajan held that a foreign national had no inherent or legally enforceable right to enter or stay in India and that marriage to an Indian citizen did not automatically confer an entitlement to conversion of an existing visa into an Entry (X-1) visa.Referring to the Supreme Court’s judgment in Louis De Raedt vs Union of India (1991), the court reiterated that the fundamental rights available to foreigners under the Constitution were confined to Article 21, concerning life and personal liberty, and did not include the right to reside and settle in India.It further observed that the grant, conversion and extension of visas, as well as the regulation of the stay of foreign nationals, fell within the domain of competent authorities under the Immigration and Foreigners Act, 2025.The court also took note of the absence of an affidavit from Akram corroborating his wife’s assertions about their matrimonial relationship, cohabitation and circumstances surrounding their marriage. It clarified, however, that the absence of such an affidavit could not, by itself, determine whether the marriage was genuine.Importantly, the High Court clarified that it had not adjudicated upon the validity or genuineness of the marriage. Its observations were confined to the woman’s claim for immigration benefits and the authorities’ examination of her application.Dismissing the petition along with pending applications, the court said any representation filed by the petitioner in future would have to be decided by the authorities in accordance with law.


