In a ruling highlighting how digital shopping platforms can use small refund adjustments to retain customers’ money within their ecosystems, the District Consumer Disputes Redressal Commission, Panchkula, has held Reliance Retail guilty of deficiency in service and unfair trade practice for diverting Re 1 from a customer’s refund into a digital reward wallet without her consent.The commission described the practice as a potential dark pattern, observing that such wallet credits could induce consumers to return to the same platform to utilise their money and make further purchases.Allowing a complaint filed by 24-year-old Nishtha Raghav, the commission directed Reliance Smart Superstore, Panchkula, and Reliance Retail Limited to jointly and severally pay her Rs 2,500 in compensation. It also imposed punitive damages of Rs 5,000, to be deposited with the Free Legal Aid State Commission, Haryana.The dispute arose from two grocery orders placed by Raghav through the JioMart application on January 23 and 25 this year. Both orders included a Munch Max chocolate bar priced at Rs 19, which was subsequently found to be unavailable.Although the platform informed her that Rs 19 would be refunded to the original mode of payment on each occasion, only Rs 18 was credited to her bank account. The remaining Re 1 was transferred to her Twid (Pay with Rewards) account.The commission noted that a bank account and a reward wallet were distinct modes of holding and utilising monetary value. It observed that a consumer could not be compelled to accept wallet credit instead of a refund to the original mode of payment, particularly when the company had represented that the amount would be returned through the latter.It further observed that Reliance had failed to produce any evidence establishing that the complainant had consented to the adjustment or accepted a disclosed refund policy permitting it.In a significant observation, the commission said that transferring part of a refund into a restricted reward wallet effectively retained the consumer’s money within the digital reward ecosystem. Such an arrangement could prompt consumers to undertake further transactions on the platform to utilise the credited amount.”This practice, particularly when repeated in both transactions without the complainant’s informed consent, raises concerns of manipulation of consumer choice and autonomy,” the order stated.Referring to the Central Consumer Protection Authority’s Guidelines for Prevention and Regulation of Dark Patterns, 2023, the commission said such practices could amount to deceptive trade practices designed to influence consumers into undertaking transactions they had not originally intended.The commission also took note of the fact that the complainant had raised a grievance through the JioMart application on February 3 and subsequently sent a legal notice on February 14, but received no satisfactory redressal.Reliance’s defence was struck off on June 26 after it failed to file a written statement despite being granted several opportunities. The commission, however, clarified that this did not automatically entitle the complainant to the relief sought and proceeded to examine her affidavit and documentary evidence on merits.Holding that the repeated diversion of refund amounts could not be treated as a mere inadvertent accounting error, the commission allowed the complaint on October 28.The opposite parties have been directed to comply with the order within 45 days of receiving its communication.


