A woman seeking to conceive through In-Vitro Fertilization (IVF) cannot be denied reproductive choices without adequate consideration of her individual health, medical fitness and informed consent, the Punjab and Haryana High Court has ruled.Dismissing the Union government’s appeal against an order permitting a woman, who had crossed the prescribed upper age limit, to undergo IVF treatment, a Division Bench of Justice Suvir Sehgal and Justice Rajesh Gaur observed: “A blanket age-based restriction, if imposed without a rational and proportional justification, may unduly infringe upon a woman’s decisional autonomy, bodily integrity and dignity, which constitute integral facets of Article 21 of the Constitution”.The case arose after a married couple, who had earlier conceived through IVF but lost one foetus during pregnancy, approached an ART clinic for treatment again. The clinic refused treatment as the woman had crossed the statutory upper age limit.The Single Bench, on May 19, allowed their petition, permitting treatment subject to an undertaking accepting responsibility for any injury or damage caused to the woman during the procedure.The Division Bench noted that the Union government’s counsel had itself proposed this safeguard before the Single Bench but subsequently challenged the order in appeal. Having proposed the undertaking, the appellants were “estopped by their own conduct and acquiescence”, the Bench observed.The court asserted that reproductive choices constituted an essential facet of the fundamental right to personal liberty guaranteed under Article 21 of the Constitution.“Any statutory restriction seeking to curtail such a right must satisfy the constitutional tests of reasonableness, non-arbitrariness and proportionality. A statutory classification to withstand scrutiny under Article 14 of the Constitution, must bear a rational nexus to the object sought to be achieved by the legislation,” it ruled.Relying on Supreme Court judgments, the High Court noted that reproductive autonomy encompassed decisions concerning reproduction, contraception, pregnancy and family planning, free from undue State interference.The Bench clarified that the Assisted Reproductive Technology (Regulation) Act, 2021, did not prescribe a combined age limit for a commissioning couple.Section 21(g) of the Act stipulates that a woman must be above 21 and below 50, while a man must be above 21 and below 55. Reading this provision with Section 2(1)(n), which defines patients as “an individual or a couple”, the court held that the legislature had recognised individuals and couples as distinct categories.”The statutory scheme does not contemplate as prescribed any cumulative and combined age restriction in respect of commissioning couple,” the court held, adding that the age criteria were individual-specific.Finding no reason to interfere with the Single Bench’s order permitting the woman to proceed with treatment, the High Court dismissed the Union government’s appeal.


